Your idea is not a secret: what founders and leaders told us about Buzz Messaging
Why we share Buzz Messaging with anyone who will challenge it, and three pieces of feedback that stayed with us: a co-founder of ICQ on Slack's noise and cost, a Match Group leader on privacy and trust, and a Blockchain.com co-founder on who owns our data.

Your idea is not a secret
Every first-time founder has the same worry: if I tell someone my idea, they'll steal it. What Josh and I have each learned on our own journeys, and what we kept hearing from successful entrepreneurs, is that your idea is not a secret. It's a problem statement, and it needs to be challenged all the time.
Feedback can qualify you out of an idea, help you refine it, or at worst push you to pivot. If you hear again and again that the problem isn't meaningful enough, or that your solution isn't disruptive or valuable enough, it doesn't mean the world is wrong and you're right. It means going back to the drawing board, from the pitch to the solution. Nothing should be immune to change.
So when we started Buzz Messaging, we went to speak to successful entrepreneurs and leaders, some from our industry and some who see it from a very different seat. We still do it every day. Here are three conversations that had a real impact on us.
A co-founder of ICQ: look hard at Buzz Work

ICQ was one of the first messaging platforms to scale. It launched in 1996, and in 1998 AOL bought Mirabilis, the company behind it, for $287 million in cash, with up to $120 million more tied to performance: as much as $407 million in total.
We had the privilege of securing 30 minutes with one of ICQ's co-founders. He is very technical, has since exited several other companies, and has supported startups ever since. We told him about our sovereignty and AI mission and the three flavours of Buzz Messaging: Personal, Incognito and Buzz Work.
After a few tough questions, we asked what our biggest challenge would be. He answered very humbly: living in the US, he doesn't feel the sovereignty pain, so he couldn't judge our chances of moving people away from WhatsApp, which he doesn't use. If you read our post about the dinner that started Buzz Messaging, you'll remember that most people in the US use iMessage rather than WhatsApp.
What he did focus us on was Buzz Work. Today he is CEO of an organisation of about 150 people that uses Slack, and two things bother him every day.
The first is noise. Early on, enthusiastic people built channels for everything, from work to funny dog outfits (I feel sorry for the dogs). That enthusiasm has gone, and people are now bombarded with endless channels and group chats that disappear and are hard to find.
The second is cost. In his view, because Slack was built in the US and is now owned by Salesforce, the cost per user keeps climbing without a clear reason, driven by shareholder expectations, the economics of scale and a wish to charge for every new integration or AI feature. For him, Slack has become expensive and, with all that noise, the opposite of a productivity tool.
His bar: if we focus on those two problems and get five customers with more than 100 users each to move away from Slack, he'd see that as a good point to talk again.
A member of Match Group's senior leadership: eat, drink and breathe privacy

Who doesn't know Tinder and Hinge? Fewer people know that both belong to Match Group, which has more than 20 brands, most of them dating apps, including Match, Meetic, OkCupid and Plenty of Fish.
We met a member of Match Group's senior leadership responsible for customer data. Imagine being responsible for some of the most sensitive and personal details of people's lives: who they fancy, what they're looking for, and the personal, often very deep conversations that lead to a first date and, these days, to a lot of marriages.
His biggest piece of feedback was that user privacy, and European standards and regulations, should be front and centre. We should eat, drink and breathe privacy in everything we build and ship, because you can gain people's trust, but once it's gone, it's gone for ever.
A co-founder of Blockchain.com: help people own their data

On a rainy London day, we cycled to Soho House White City for a session with one of Blockchain.com's co-founders. Blockchain.com is the global crypto platform that many people use to buy and manage their crypto. He talked about his journey. I recommend his book, because I won't do him justice here.
Like a lot of founders I've met, he was happy to give me five minutes at the end, so I told him about Buzz Messaging and asked for his opinion. To my surprise, he was very enthusiastic about sovereign technology. He sees it as a true wave that we should definitely focus on, and a real problem he had dealt with himself, building a company in the UK.
His view is that data will become the new commodity, even a currency, and that the companies that help people take control of their data and truly own it will lead the future. Innovating there will go a long way.
More to come
Every now and then we'll share more of the feedback we've had along the way. A small teaser: the next post on this topic covers a very tough conversation with an executive from Wix.com, from when we started.